Custom Cookie Orders Pricing Guide


About Custom Cookies...


Custom cookies sure are pricey! Why? The time commitment involved in designing, hand decorating and packaging each cookie is a “Labor of Love”. This does not even include the quality ingredients used to make each small batch! I realize that my cookies are an investment, not always in line with every budget. Couture custom cookies are a luxury item, and prices will reflect this.

Pricing Guideline Budget

I’M A BASIC B” – AKA “Basic Design”. Don’t let the name basic deter you! These are simple, but have an elegant, classy and clean design. Incorporates a standard shape with 2-3 colors

I’M SOOO EXTRA – AKA “Elaborate Design”. You’re the type that wants to make a statement! These are detailed designs with higher levels of intricacy that can incorporate hand painting, calligraphy, logos, characters, hand cut shapes, metallic gilding, florals, multi colors, etc.

Flavors Offered

  • Vanilla Bean (most popular)
  • Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips
  • Raspberry Lemonade 
  • Strawberry
  • Chocolate 
  • Apple Spice 
  • Lemon 
  • Pumpkin Spice
  • Gingerbread 
  • Orange Creamsicle

Menu / Price List

How to Place an order

EMAIL: with the following information:

  • Name:
  • Pickup Date:
  • Quantity:
  • Item: (Favors, Small or Large Gift Box,   Keepsake Cookie, etc.)
  • Theme: (e.g.: Girl Baby Shower; please specify colors)
  • Budget: (Basic or Elaborate Design)
  • Flavor: Vanilla, Chocolate,etc (Please see above for Flavor Options)
  • Notes: Please include any additional details such as favor ribbon color, request for boxed favors, etc. 


Please Note: 

1) Once info is submitted, a quote will be provided within 2 business days.

2) If you accept the quote, an invoice will be sent to you requesting a 50% deposit.

  • Your order is NOT secure until the 50% deposit has been paid.
  • Invoice is ONLY valid for 48 hours and must be paid within this time frame.(After this time frame, invoice is voided without notification)
  • Remaining balance MUST be paid two weeks prior to order pickup date. (A reminder will be sent for the remaining balance. If balance is not paid, order will be cancelled, and deposit will be refunded, minus the $25 cancellation fee.)

3) Cookies must be picked up in a timely manner on the agreed upon timeframe. Pickup available in:

  • Annadale, Staten Island or 
  • FiDi (Wall St area), Manhattan.


  • How far in advance should I place my order?

I require two weeks’ notice to fulfill an order, but please keep in mind I am often booked several months in advance. 

  • Is there a minimum to place an order?

Minimum purchase of $100 is required to place an order

  • How long will the cookies stay fresh?

Each cookie is individually heat sealed and will stay fresh for up to two weeks.

  • What happens if I need to cancel my order?

We all know life happens! If your order is cancelled at least 14 days  prior to pickup date, a refund will be issued, minus a $25 cancellation fee. Unfortunately, cancellations made with less than 14 days' notice are NOT refundable. I am a small baking business, which means work has already been invested and supplies already purchased.

  • Do you ship?

Unfortunately, NYC cottage food laws prohibit shipping out of state.

  • Do you deliver?

Sorry, no deliveries available. Cookies must be picked up in Annadale, Staten Island or FiDi (Wall St area), Manhattan.